Should a beginner get a boot or a shoe?
It depends on the terrain and your ankle history. Mid-cut boots, like the Salomon and Oboz listings here, wrap higher around the ankle and are generally chosen for uneven or rocky trails. Low-cut shoes, like the Hoka, Columbia, and Adidas listings, are lighter and usually break in faster, but offer less lateral ankle coverage. Neither is objectively 'better' — match the cut to where you'll actually hike.
Is Gore-Tex better than a brand's own waterproofing system?
Gore-Tex is a third-party licensed membrane used across many outdoor brands, which is why three listings in this group name it directly. The Oboz boot instead uses Oboz's own B-Dry system. Both are functioning waterproofing approaches per their listings; the main practical difference is that Gore-Tex carries broader name recognition, while a house system's performance is harder to compare across brands without hands-on testing, which none of these listings substitute for.
How long does it take to break in a hiking boot versus a shoe?
Nothing in these listings states a break-in timeline, so this can't be answered from the titles alone. Generally speaking, mid-cut boots with stiffer uppers tend to need a longer adjustment period than low-cut shoes, which is one more reason to weigh cut height carefully rather than assuming any boot will feel comfortable immediately.
Do these come in both men's and women's sizing?
As listed, the Salomon and Hoka products are titled specifically as women's, while the Columbia, Oboz, and Adidas products are titled as men's. If you need the opposite gender's last or sizing for any of these lines, check the seller's other listings, since this specific list only covers the sizing stated in each title.
Which of these is best for wet or muddy trail conditions?
Waterproofing is named in every listing here, either as Gore-Tex or a proprietary system, so all five are positioned for wet-trail use per their titles. None of the listings specify outsole lug depth or tread pattern, though, so grip in mud specifically isn't something that can be confirmed from the title alone.