Do I actually need shower shoes in a dorm, or is that overkill?
Communal showers see continuous bare-foot traffic on tile that rarely fully dries, which is the exact environment fungal infections like athlete's foot spread in. None of these listings guarantee protection, but drain-hole soles and non-slip treads are the standard features aimed at reducing that exposure, so it's a reasonable precaution rather than overkill.
Should I get an open slide or a closed clog like the Crocs?
An open slide dries faster and slips on quicker between stalls, which most of the shower-specific listings here are built around. A closed clog gives more foot coverage and doubles as everyday footwear, but it wasn't marketed with drain holes or a shower-specific tread, so it's a trade-off between coverage and shower-specific design.
Can shower shoes themselves get moldy or smelly?
Any shoe that stays wet without draining or drying can develop odor over time. That's why drain holes and quick-dry materials are the features worth checking in the listing rather than assuming any slide-style shoe will do — pairing them with a fast-drying towel and letting them air out helps too.
Is the water shoe a good substitute for a dedicated shower shoe?
It's built and marketed for kayaking, diving, and river use rather than shower floors specifically, so it's a reasonable dual-purpose option if you already want water shoes for outdoor activity, but it's a closed athletic shoe rather than a quick on-off slide, which matters for the pace of a shared bathroom.
Does foot powder mean I can skip shower shoes altogether?
No — the powder is described as treating and relieving symptoms of fungal issues that have already started, not preventing exposure to a shared shower floor. It's a reasonable backup, but it addresses a different stage of the problem than the shoes do.
Why does a mesh caddy matter for shower shoe shopping?
It doesn't affect fungal exposure directly, but it solves the practical logistics of a shared bathroom — carrying toiletries without setting them on a communal surface. It's included here as the accessory that rounds out an actual dorm shower routine, not as a substitute for footwear.