Whatever Happened to the Sears Wish Book?

I'm on the living-room floor, carpet fibers pressed into my elbows, and the book is open across both my knees because it will not close flat — it never closes flat, it's too thick and too used. There's a pen with a chewed cap that isn't mine, because somebody else in the house got to this page first and already circled the Lite-Brite. I circle it again anyway. That's not redundant. That's a vote.

That book is the Sears Wish Book, and if you grew up anywhere in this country before the internet ate the whole ritual, you know exactly which floor I'm talking about, even if it was carpeted differently in your house. So what actually was it, who made it, and why did it stop showing up?

It Started During the Depression, Not the Boom

Contemporaneous accounts and Sears' own archival history put the first dedicated Christmas catalog in 1933 — 87 pages, with roughly 25 pages of toys and the rest gifts for adults, mailed out in the depths of the Great Depression. That timing matters more than it gets credit for: this wasn't a company flexing during flush times, it was a mail-order retailer betting that people would still want to imagine a good Christmas even when money was tight. As I remember it — and I'm aware I never lived through the Depression, so this is inherited nostalgia, not personal memory — that's part of why the book always felt aspirational rather than transactional. You weren't shopping. You were dreaming with a pen.

It took decades to get the name everyone actually uses. Sears' own archival record and multiple retrospectives place the official rebrand to "The Wish Book" in 1968, by which point the catalog had grown to roughly 608 pages — hundreds of them toys, hundreds more general gifts. That's the version most of us actually remember: the fat one, the one that needed two hands.

What We Get Wrong: It Wasn't "The" Sears Catalog

Here's the correction I actually needed to make while writing this. My memory — possibly improved, or more likely just flattened, by time — used to treat "the Sears Wish Book" and "the Sears catalog" as the same object. They weren't. Sears ran a separate, much larger general merchandise catalog for most of the twentieth century — the "Big Book" — selling everything from tools to furniture to entire mail-order houses. Reporting from the time confirms Sears announced in January 1993 that it was exiting the general catalog business entirely, shutting down the Big Book after roughly a century of mail-order sales.

The Wish Book is a different, smaller, seasonal animal — a holiday toy-and-gift catalog that rode alongside the Big Book for decades. When the Big Book died in 1993, the Wish Book didn't die with it; it shrank, and its publication became less consistent, but it kept appearing in some form for years afterward. If you've ever heard someone say "Sears stopped mailing catalogs in 1993" and pictured the Wish Book specifically, that's the popular shorthand getting the two publications tangled — a mix-up I was making myself until I actually checked.

Why a Catalog Mattered This Much

It wasn't really about the toys, or not only about the toys. It was that there was exactly one version of this book, and it showed up in every mailbox in the country at roughly the same time, and there was no way to personalize it, filter it, or skip to page 40 without physically flipping there. Every kid I knew had the same pages worn soft in the same places — the toy aisle didn't have an algorithm, and neither did the Wish Book. You dog-eared a page to claim it, you circled an item to make your case to a parent, and you handed the book to a sibling who was going to do the exact same thing three pages later. It was a shared cultural object in a way almost nothing marketed to kids is anymore.

What Actually Happened to It

The honest timeline is longer and messier than "it just stopped one year."

So the honest answer isn't "discontinued in 1993." It's: a separate general catalog died in 1993, the seasonal Wish Book limped on through a shrinking version of itself for almost two more decades, took a real break after 2011, came back once as a nostalgia play in 2017, and then the parent company collapsed into bankruptcy the following year, taking the whole ritual down with it for good.

What Replaced It

Nothing replaced the specific thing it was, which is different from saying nothing replaced its function. Online shopping replaced the function — you can still see every toy that exists, still narrow it down, still make a list. What it lost was the single-shared-object part: there's no modern equivalent where every kid in the country is looking at the same 600 pages at the same time. Personalized feeds and targeted ads do the opposite job on purpose — they show you what you, specifically, are likely to want, which is more efficient and considerably lonelier as a shared childhood experience. My mother didn't need a recommendation engine to know what I wanted. She just needed to see which pages were worn through.

Back on the Carpet

I'll be honest about how far I'll take this: I don't think the actual shopping experience today is worse. It's faster, it's more accurate, and nobody's disappointed on Christmas morning because the item sold out before the order form reached the warehouse, which absolutely used to happen. But there was a specific kind of anticipation the book created that a browser tab never will — the page stayed circled for weeks, not the length of a session. You could go back and look at your own commitment to a Lite-Brite over and over, and so could everyone else in the house, and that was sort of the point. I live under the LAX flight path, I still drive to Randy's for the donut on the roof, and I still think a rerun means more at the hour I originally watched it. So sure — I miss the book. I'm allowed to.

Legit disclosure. This is an independently researched nostalgia-history article. It contains no affiliate links, paid placement or sponsorship. Personal recollections are identified as such and should not be interpreted as documentary evidence. Facts (the 1933 debut, the 1968 "Wish Book" rebrand, the January 1993 general-catalog closure, the Wish Book's continued run through 2011, the 2017 revival, and the October 2018 Chapter 11 filing) are drawn from public reporting and archival sources — Wikipedia's "Sears Wish Book" entry, Sears' own archival history (searsarchives.claeys.co), CNN Money, NBC News/TODAY, CBS News, PRNewswire, and Chief Marketer. Donald Kingzley's own recollections are personal and impressionistic, and are presented as such.

Corrections: email us